• 0800 015 0340
  • Contact Us
    • All Offices
    • Leeds City Centre
    • Bradford City Centre
    • Huddersfield
    • Wakefield
    • Halifax
    • Morley
    • Horbury
    • Guiseley
Menu
  • About Us
  • Vision & Values
    • Prizes & Awards
  • Your Team
  • Media
    • The Hub
  • Free Training
  • Careers
  • Testimonials
Chadwick Lawrence
Trustpilot
Services
  • Business ServicesView all >
    • Employer Services
      • BoxHR
      • Coronavirus (COVID-19) Updates
      • FAQs

      Outsourced Employment support allowing you to run your business

      More Info

    • Complete Property Solutions
      • Development
      • Property Litigation
      • Commercial Property
      • Leasehold management
      • Leases of commercial premises for landlords or tenants
      • Mortgage finance & security
      • Sales and Purchases of Property
      • Commercial land development
      • Land acquisition for residential development & new build sales
      • Option agreements & conditional contracts
      • Planning agreements
      • Boundary disputes, land ownership & rights
      • Breaches of leases and rent and service charge issues
      • Claims against property professionals
      • Lease renewals, termination & dilapidations
    • Corporate and Contracts
      • Banking & Finance
      • Commercial Contracts
      • Corporate Advisory
      • Mergers and Acquisitions
      • LINK
    • Corporate Recovery & Insolvency
      • Administration
      • Fraudulent Trading
      • Wrongful Trading
      • Preferences
      • Transactions at an Undervalue
      • Director Disqualification
      • Company Restoration
      • Winding-Up Petitions
      • Statutory Demands
      • Individual Voluntary Arrangements
      • Bankruptcy
      • Validation Orders
      • Administrative Receivership
      • Company Voluntary Arrangements
      • Liquidations
      • FAQs

      Tailored solutions design to get businesses back to financial health

      More Info

    • Intellectual Property
      • Contracts and Licenses
      • Trademarks
      • Design Rights
      • Enforcement
      • Restrictive Covenants
      • FAQs

      We make it our business to protect your business

      More Info

    • Litigation in Business
      • Contractual Disputes
      • Construction Solicitors
      • Professional Negligence
      • Restrictive Covenant Solicitors
      • Banking & Finance
      • Debt Collection & Recovery
      • Directors and Partnership Internal Disputes
      • FAQs

      Disputes are a fact of business, Costly resolutions don’t have to be

      More Info

    • Media Law and Reputation
      • Pre-Publication
      • After Publication
      • Online Reputation & Presence
      • Defamation
      • Harrasment
      • Privacy and Confidence
    • Regulatory Services
      • Coroners Inquests
      • Licensing
      • Sports Regulation
      • Health and safety investigations
      • Trading Standards
      • Box GDPR
      • BoxLegal
      • Immigration & Workers
      • Transport Law
    • Sports Law
      • Club Services
      • Player / Coach Services
      • Regulatory Services
      • Private Client Services

      As yorkshire’s key players in sports law we understand it’s not just about the game.

      More Info

  • Personal ServicesView all >
    • Road Traffic & Motoring Law
      • Drink Driving
      • Speeding & Disqualification
      • Driving Without Due Care & Attention
      • Use of a Mobile Phone
      • Driving Without Insurance
      • Drug Driving
      • Dangerous Driving
      • Failure to Provide Information
      • Road Traffic and Motoring Offences

      We are not judgemental and our clients benefit from our high quality advice and representation.

      More Info

    • Defamation and Reputation
      • Pre-Publication
      • After Publication
      • Online Reputation & Presence
      • Defamation
      • Harassment
      • Privacy and Confidence
    • Dispute Resolution
      • Court Proceedings
      • Debt Matters
      • Contentious Probate
      • Private Contract Disputes
      • Professional Negligence
      • Data Protection GDPR breaches
      • FAQs

      Experience, understanding and results are our greatest assets

      More Info

    • Employee Services
      • Disciplinary
      • Grievance
      • Employment Tribunal
      • Settlement Agreements
      • Restrictive Covenants
      • Exit Packages
      • FAQS

      We’re by your side when it comes to standing up for your employee rights

      More Info

    • Family Solicitors
      • Divorce
      • Civil Partnership
      • Financial Settlements after Divorce or Dissolution
      • Pre-nuptial and Post-nuptial Agreements
      • Adoption
      • Grandparents Rights
      • Funding Your Case
      • Mediation Solicitors
      • Financial Provision for Children
      • Separation Agreement Solicitors
      • Child Arrangements and Covid-19
      • Cohabitation Agreements
      • Collaborative Law Solicitors
      • FAQs

      We’re not here to judge… Just a helping hand for you and your family

      More Info

    • Home & Property Services
      • Remortgaging
      • Buying and Selling
      • Property FAQs

      We’re not a removal company… But we do remove the stress and hassle

      More Info

    • Residential Property Disputes
      • Land/Buildings Disputes
      • Claims arising out of Property Contracts
      • Disputes between Co-Owners
      • Professional Negligence Arising Out of Property Advice or Transactions
      • Defects to new build properties
      • Tenant Disrepair Claim Service

      We act on behalf of investors, landlords, homeowners and leaseholders in relation to all disputes.

      More Info

    • Medical Negligence
      • Accident & Emergency
      • Amputations
      • Birth Injuries
      • Brain Injuries
      • Cancer Cases
      • Cardiology
      • Ear, Nose & Throat
      • Eye Conditions & Surgery
      • Gastroenterology
      • General Practitioner (GP)
      • Genetic Conditions
      • Gynaecology
      • Neurology / Nerve Damage
      • Orthopaedics & Rheumatology
      • Paediatrics
      • Respiratory Disorders
      • Spinal Cord Injuries
      • Surgery
      • Urology & Renal
      • Vascular Conditions & Vascular Surgery

      You’ve been through enough… We’ll take it from here and fight for what you deserve

      More Info

    • Personal Injury Solicitors
      • Animal Related Injury Claims
      • Armed Forces Injury Claims
      • Slip, Trip or Fall Accident Claim
      • Accident At Work Claims
      • Road Traffic Accident Solicitors
      • FAQs

      Our specialist team of experts are right by your side

      More Info

    • Wills & Probate Solicitors
      • Court of Protection
      • Disputed Wills
      • FAQs
      • International Legal Matters
      • Lasting Powers of Attorney (LPA)
      • Succession Planning
      • Trusts
      • UK Tax Planning

      It’s good to know everything will be taken care of exactly how you want

      More Info

Trustpilot

You are here:Home > Complete Property Solutions > No need to put that in writing – Re: Lumley v Foster & Co Group Ltd and others [2022] EWHC 54 (TCC)

  • Quick Jump
    • About Us
    • Business Services
    • Careers
    • Client Care & Complaints
    • Contact Us
    • Cookie Policy
    • Coronavirus (COVID-19) Updates
    • Development and Plot Sales
    • Divorce Solicitors
    • Financial Conduct Authority Investigation
    • Legal About Us
    • Media
    • National Minimum Wage Investigations
    • Personal Services
    • Pricing Transparency
    • Privacy Notice
    • Prize Draw Terms & Conditions
    • Property Dispute Resolution
    • Separation Specialist Solicitors
    • Sitemap
    • Terms & Conditions
    • The Chadwick Lawrence Way
    • The Hub
    • Transport Law
    • We are Yorkshire's Legal People
    • Yorkshire Lawyer Network
No need to put that in writing – Re: Lumley v Foster & Co Group Ltd and others [2022] EWHC 54 (TCC)

13
Apr 2022

No need to put that in writing – Re: Lumley v Foster & Co Group Ltd and others [2022] EWHC 54 (TCC)

The excitement builds as the months of contemplating, planning, and changing your mind on the scope of the building works you wish to undertake to your property ends: the time has come to instruct the contractor. No matter if you are a consumer or business, there is always a temptation to agree to the works verbally without a written agreement.

The case of Lumley v Foster highlights the importance of obtaining a written agreement with the correct party. Litigation is never in the forefront of your mind, however unforeseen issues including poor workmanship, defects, delays, costs pressure and so on, may force you to consider your position. If you have not entered into a written agreement with the correct party at the start of the instruction it may have a significant impact on you obtaining what you deserve.

In this instance, Ms Lumley was a residential homeowner who received an advertising flyer from “Foster & Co” outlining the variety of construction works the business can provide. Ms Lumley opted to contact the business and arranged a site meeting for 21 June 2016, a Mr Foster attended the meeting. Here, the parties agreed the scope of the works in broad terms as well as a contract price of £100,000.00.

Thereafter, the building works commenced however Ms Lumley soon became concerned that the workmanship was sub-standard. This culminated in the builders’ downing tools and Ms Lumley being left with a “scarcely habitable” home. Considering which, Ms Lumley issued Court Proceedings in breach of contract against the following six defendants: –

  • Foster & Co Group Ltd (Defendant 1)
  • Mr Nicholas Foster (Defendant 2)
  • Mrs Joanna Foster (Defendant 3)
  • Foster and Co Developments Ltd (Defendant 4)
  • Foster and Co Construction Ltd (Defendant 5)
  • Foster and Co Ltd (Defendant 6)

It was the position of Ms Lumley that she has contracted with Mr Foster who was acting on behalf of one of the said six defendants: however, in the defence it was put forward that the contract was concluded with Foster and Co Construction Limited, namely defendant 5.

In support of her claim, Ms Lumley argued that the advertisement flyer was in the name of Foster & Co and when making the initial call the telephone was answered in the name of that company. In addition, Mr Foster attended the site meeting in a company vehicle with the logo of Foster & Co and a witness attested that during the meeting Mr Foster stated he would be personally responsible for the works and spoke about Foster & Co, but not Foster and Co Construction Ltd.

During the course of the works invoices were provided to Ms Lumley in the name of Foster & Co but the bank account into which payment was made was for an alternative legal entity, namely Foster and Co Construction Limited.

When considering an oral contract the Court will ask, “what a reasonable person, furnished with the relevant information, would conclude” (Hamid v Francis Bradshaw Partnership [2013]).

The conclusion of the Court was that the contract had been entered into with Ms Lumley and Mr Foster directly: therefore, Mr Foster would be personally liable for any breach of contract and the six defendants could not be found liable.

The primary reasoning provided by the Court was that Mr Foster gave the impression to Ms Lumley that the agreement was with him and that he could be personally trusted to ensure the works were completed to a high/reasonable standard. At this juncture, Mr Foster should have documented and made it clear that the contract was with a different entity, which he failed to do.

The key point is to ensure that you obtain a written agreement which clearly identifies the scope of the work, the price and who you are in contract with. In addition, it would be prudent to undertake the following steps before agreeing to the works, no matter how small your project is: –

  • Complete thorough due diligence on the contractor, including a review of their financial position, ask for confirmation of appropriate insurance and any reviews of their previous work
  • A written contract should be in place at the start of the project, with the correct party, to help limit future disputes that may arise. There are standard form documents, such as the JCT Homeowner Building Contract, which are simple and straightforward to use
  • Maintain records of all correspondence you receive from the contractor, including emails and any supporting documentation, such as a brochure, proposed plans, and invoices
  • Seek early independent legal advice where required

For more information or advice on your position, please contact Andrew Dickinson (0113 225 8811 or [email protected]) or your usual Chadwick Lawrence contact.

< Back to Media Hub

  • Like this ? Share with friends
CQC – Cambridgeshire emergency care services affected by staff shortages

28
Jun 2022

CQC – Cambridgeshire emergency care services affected by staff shortages

A report by the Care Quality Commission has warned that staff shortages in the health sector need to be addressed to “reduce the risk of harm to people” in Cambridgeshire, adding that emergency care services were “struggling to meet patient need”.   The report said that, despite staff going “above and beyond”, patients did not…

Read More

Ambassador appointed to ‘shake up’ women’s health in England

28
Jun 2022

Ambassador appointed to ‘shake up’ women’s health in England

England’s first ambassador for women’s health is calling for “one-stop shops” where women can have their health needs taken care of, the aim of the role being to close the “gender health gap”.   Dame Lesley Regan, a practicing doctor, wants to make it easier for women and girls to access care such as smear…

Read More

Get in touch


  • 0800 015 0340
  • [email protected]

Social Media


Trustpilot

Business Services


Box GDPR

Business Property Solicitors

Complete Property Solutions

Corporate Recovery & Insolvency

Corporate and Contracts

Employer Services

Intellectual Property

LINK

Litigation Solicitors

Media Law and Reputation

Regulatory Services

Sports Law

Personal Services


Defamation and Reputation

Dispute Resolution

Employee Services

Family Solicitors

Home & Property Services

Medical Negligence

Personal Injury Solicitors

Residential Property Disputes

Road Traffic & Motoring Law

Wills & Probate Solicitors

Chadwick Lawrence
  • Pricing Transparency
  • Legal About Us
  • Client Care & Complaints
  • Privacy Notice
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Sitemap

© Copyright 2022. Website design by Fantastic Media.

‹›×